On a cold December afternoon in 1910, a young woman stepped onto Fifth Avenue and vanished without a trace.

Dorothy Arnold was twenty-five years old, wealthy, well-educated, and firmly embedded in New York's elite society. The daughter of a perfume magnate and the niece of a Supreme Court justice, she seemed protected by privilege. Yet after a routine afternoon of shopping, casual conversations, and ordinary errands, Dorothy disappeared. No struggle was witnessed. No ransom was demanded. No confirmed sighting followed.

More than a century later, her disappearance remains one of the oldest and most perplexing unsolved missing-person cases in American history.

The Vanishing Heiress, now fully revised and expanded, offers a gripping narrative investigation into this enduring Gilded Age mystery. Drawing on extensive archival research, private correspondence, contemporary newspaper accounts, and modern historical analysis, author Eliza Hawthorne reconstructs Dorothy Arnold's final known hours while examining the social pressures, investigative failures, and cultural blind spots that shaped the case.

This edition responds directly to reader feedback and new research, delivering deeper historical immersion, improved pacing, and a more emotionally resonant portrait of the woman behind the headlines. Dorothy Arnold was not merely a missing socialite. She was a Bryn Mawr graduate with literary ambitions, a young woman seeking independence in a rigidly controlled world. Just weeks before her disappearance, she asked her father for permission to live on her own in Greenwich Village, a request that revealed both her restlessness and her resolve.

Readers will follow Dorothy's final path through Manhattan, from bookshops and confectioners to the icy streets where her trail abruptly ends. Along the way, the book examines every major theory surrounding her fate, including voluntary disappearance, concealed tragedy, and investigative misdirection. Each possibility is presented with clarity and empathy, without sensationalism or forced conclusions.

Inside this revised edition, readers will discover:

• A meticulously reconstructed timeline of Dorothy Arnold's final day

• The role of private detectives and early twentieth-century policing

• How wealth and reputation influenced the investigation and media coverage

• The emotional toll of unresolved loss on families and communities

• Why this case continues to resonate in modern true crime media

As the inaugural title in the Shadows of the Past historical true crime series, The Vanishing Heiress sets the tone for a collection devoted to forgotten cases, unresolved questions, and the people history left behind.

Perfect for readers of historical true crime, unsolved cold cases, and narrative nonfiction, this revised edition invites readers to revisit a mystery that refuses to fade. Dorothy Arnold's fate remains unknown, but her story still demands to be told.

Some mysteries endure because the truth was never allowed to surface.
Begin the revised and expanded investigation today.

• We started tracking this book on October 12, 2024.
• This book was $3.99 when we started tracking it.
• The price of this book has changed 19 times in the past 469 days.
• The current price of this book is FREE last checked 2 hours ago.
• The lowest price to date was FREE last reached on January 24, 2026.
• This book has been FREE 2 times since we started tracking it.
• The highest price to date was $7.99 last reached on January 12, 2026.
• This book has been $7.99 one time since we started tracking it.
• This book is currently at its lowest price since we started tracking it.

• Biographies & MemoirsTrue CrimeAbductions, Kidnappings & Missing Persons

• Text-to-Speech: Disabled
• Lending: Disabled
• Print Length: 162 Pages
• File Size: 105 KB